Questions About the Short Film Selection for the Goya Awards

—–Update 11/10/2016—–

Today the list of selected short films has been published again with a necessary correction from the Film Academy. More short films have been added, completing the quotas for Animation and Fiction. Documentary ultimately remains at only 8 and does not complete the quota of 10 documentaries.

The news appeared in Cortosfera magazine. On the Academy’s website, only the updated list of short films has been published.

I have updated the lists I published with the new short films in red

—–

Yesterday we learned of the short film selection for the Goya Awards and, as expected, with several surprises.

Congratulations to all those selected; among them are several short films that I distribute, so I am very pleased about that.

The selection is published on the Film Academy website and has also been published in Cortosfera magazine.

These are the selected short films:

Fiction

  1. Bla, Bla, Bla, directed and produced by Álexis Morante
  2. Disco Inferno, directed by Alice Waddington and produced by Alice Waddington and Yadira Ávalos
  3. El trastero, directed by Gaizka Urresti and produced by Gaizka Urresti and Oihana Olea
  4. En la azotea, directed by Damiá Serra and produced by Lita Roig and Sergi Casamitjana
  5. Graffiti, directed by Lluís Quílez Sala and produced by Esther Velasco, Cristian Guijarro and Lluís Quílez Sala
  6. Hermanos, directed by Javier Roldán and produced by Félix Tusell Sánchez
  7. Hostal Edén, directed by Gonzaga Manso and produced by Luis Manso
  8. Jingle, directed by Marta Aledo and produced by Jorge Moreno and Luis Collar
  9. La invitación, directed by Susana Casares and produced by María Zamora Morcillo and Stefan Schmitz
  10. No me quites, directed by Laura Jou and produced by J.A. Bayona and Oriol Maymó
  11. Timecode, directed by Juanjo Giménez Peña and produced by Arturo Méndiz, Daniel Villanueva and Juanjo Giménez Peña
  12. Vainilla, directed by Juan Beiro and produced by Carlota Coronado and Giovanni Maccelli
  13. Yo, presidenta, directed by Arancha Echevarría Carcero and produced by Pilar Sánchez Díaz
  14. Zero, directed by David Victori and produced by David Victori, Eduardo Verástegui, Ignacio Lacosta, Juan Ignacio Peña, Michael Fassbender, Liza Marshall, Ridley Scott and Sebastian Mery
  15. Vida en Marte, directed by José Manuel Carrasco and produced by Arturo Ruiz Serrano

Documentary

  1. Cabezas habladoras, directed and produced by Juan Vicente Córdoba
  2. Esperanza, directed and produced by Álvaro Longoria
  3. Palabras de Caramelo, directed by Juan Antonio Moreno Amador and produced by Juan Antonio Moreno Amador and Silvia Venegas Venegas
  4. The Resurrection Club, directed by Álvaro Corcuera and Guillermo Abril, and produced by Bernabé Rico and Olmo Figueredo González-Quevedo
  5. 23 de mayo, directed and produced by David Martín de los Santos
  6. El baile de los infantes, directed by Javier Dampierre and Jokin Pascual and produced by Jokin Pascual
  7. Sin Dios ni Santa María, directed by Helena Girón and Samuel Martín Delgado and produced by Samuel M.Delgado
  8. Tout le monde alme le bord de la mer, directed by Keina Espiñeira and produced by Lourdes Pérez Izquierdo

Animation

  1. Amore d’inverno, directed by Isabel Herguera García and produced by Alessandro Ingaria, Gianmarco Serra and Isabel Herguera García
  2. Darrel, directed by Alain Carabantes Person and Marc Briones Piulachs and produced by Daniel Martínez Lara
  3. Decorado, directed by Alberto Vázquez and produced by Arturo Olea, Chelo Loureiro, Iván Miñambres and Nicolás Schmerkin
  4. Down by Love, directed and produced by José Corral Llorente
  5. I said I would never talk about politics, directed and produced by Aitor Oñederra
  6. Just the Beginning, directed by Abraham López Guerrero and produced by Manu Carbajo
  7. Oa, directed by Jaime Maestro Sellés and produced by Carlos Escutia García
  8. Portrait of a wind-up maker, directed and produced by Darío Pérez Moreno
  9. Made in Spain, directed by Coke Riobóo and produced by Coke Riobóo and Lourdes Villagomez Oviedo
  10. Uka, directed by Valle Comba Canales and produced by David Castro González and Valle Comba Canales

Analyzing the selection after the posts I have published on this subject, several doubts and questions arise. Especially because the participation quotas stipulated in the rules in Article 9 have not been completed:

9. Participation quotas. Preselection.
From among the short films in competition that meet all of these Rules, the Commission chosen by the Board of Directors for this purpose shall select a maximum of 15 fiction short films, a maximum of 10 animation short films and a maximum of 10 documentary short films, with any of the categories potentially having a number of short films below the stated numbers, to proceed to the first voting phase.

In this post I list the questions that arise after seeing the selection and to which I have no answer:

  • Why are there 14 selected in Fiction and not 15? Are there not short films of sufficient quality to complete the list and participate in the Goya Awards?
  • Why are there 8 selected in Animation? Are there not 2 more animation short films with sufficient quality?
  • Why are there only 4 selected in Documentary and not 10? Why have two of the most important short films of this year been left out, such as 23 de mayo and Sin Dios ni Santa Maria? If we are objective and adhere to the festivals, 23 de mayo has achieved 5 selections in national festivals, one award and one international selection (Seattle) that qualifies for the Goya Awards, and Sin Dios ni Santa Maria 3 selections in festivals and two international ones (Ann Arbor and Vila do Conde). Both short films appeared in the post I published in June.
  • So… what is the purpose of the festival filter?
  • What are the Commission’s reasons for leaving out these two documentaries?
  • Are the four selected documentaries already nominated?
  • Who are the members of the Film Academy Commission?
  • Why have the registration statistics not been published?
  • Why are there no short film or documentary representatives in the Film Academy?

If you know any of these answers or have more questions, I would love to receive your comments.